Instant Pot Butterfinger Cheesecake

This Instant Pot Butterfinger Cheesecake is a decadent peanut butter cheesecake on a graham cracker crust packed with crushed Butterfinger candy, and topped off with a chocolate ganache. This cheesecake will soon become your new obsession!

Jump to Recipe

BAKING TIPS FOR INSTANT POT CHEESECAKES

Cheesecakes are SUPER easy to make in the Instant Pot. Once you make your first one, you will never want to go back to the traditional method. However, there are a few things I have learned about using the Instant Pot method that will make your first time a little easier.

1. Do not over mix your batter. If you over mix (particularly the eggs) the texture and consistency will not be right after baking.

So, mix as little as possible while still making sure everything is combined well.

2. I recommend baking the crust before adding in the filling, HOWEVER it is not necessary. It just gives it that perfect crust texture.

3. WHEN THE CHEESECAKE IS FINISHED IN THE INSTANT POT, IT WILL LOOK UNDERCOOKED. DO NOT, I REPEAT, DO NOT ADD IT BACK IN OR ONCE IT IS SET IT WILL BE DRY AND OVERCOOKED! If you place the cheesecake in for 40 minutes and allow to naturally release for 10, it will be the perfect consistency once it is set.

SERVINGS TIPS AND VARIATIONS FOR INSTANT POT BUTTERFINGER CHEESECAKE

It is best to make this cheesecake the day BEFORE you want to serve it. Cheesecakes need to set overnight in the fridge before serving to make sure they are completely set.

I always make the ganache and whipped cream right before serving. Once the cheesecake is nice and cold it will harden the ganache faster.

You can change up this recipe simply by substituting in your favorite candy bar! You can add Snickers, Reese’s, or really whatever you want! This recipe is so versatile that you can personalize it to fit your family.

PRO TIP: To get the perfect slice, use a butcher knife and run under very hot water for 1-2 minutes per side to get the knife hot. Wipe off any access water and make your first slice. Run the knife under water again and repeat.

INGREDIENTS TO MAKE AN INSTANT POT BUTTERFINGER CHEESECAKE

For the crust:

Graham Crackers- about 1 ½ packs

Butter

For the filling:

Cream Cheese– Softened to room temperature. If you do not soften your cream cheese you WILL have a lumpy cheesecake, and nobody likes that. Also, use a high quality cream cheese like Philadelphia, it is worth it.

Sugar

Flour– Used to thicken the cheesecake

Vanilla Extract– Pure if you have it, if not, imitation is fine as well.

Peanut Butter– Smooth

Heavy Cream

Eggs

Butterfinger Candy Bars

Whipped cream and mini Butterfinger candy for topping

HOW TO MAKE AN INSTANT POT BUTTERFINGER CHEESECAKE

Make sure your cream cheese is at room temperature, then preheat your oven to 350F. Prepare a 7″ springform pan by spraying generously with non-stick spray. You can also add a round of parchment on the bottom if you want added protection

Add the graham crackers into a food processor and pulse until you have a fine crumb. Add the melted butter and pulse until combined.

Pour the crumbs into the bottom of the prepared pan and use the back of a spoon to press and form the crust bringing the crumbs up the sides about 1 inch.

Bake the crust for about 10 minutes then remove and let cool.

In the bowl of a stand mixer, cream the cream cheese on high speed for 4-5 minutes until soft, fluffy, and there are no lumps.

Slowly add in the sugar and flour and mix for an additional minute.

Add in the peanut butter and mix until smooth and combined. Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl.

Next, add in vanilla and heavy cream. Start mixing on low speed and slowly increase to high for about 1 minute. Scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl and mix for about 30 seconds to combine and remaining ingredients.

Last, add eggs, one at a time, and mix until just combined.

Fold in the crushed Butterfingers with a spatula.

Pour the batter over the crust and tap the pan on the counter to remove any air bubbles.

Cover the pan completely with aluminum foil and place on a trivet in the Instant Pot and add one cup of water.

Seal the Instant Pot and bake on high pressure for 40 minutes and allow a natural release for 10 minutes.

Remove from the Instant Pot and allow to cool to room temperature. Place in the refrigerator and allow to set over night.

TOPPINGS

I love pairing this cheesecake with a semi-sweet chocolate ganache, whipped cream, and crushed Butterfinger candy. Add whatever toppings you have on hand or just leave plain.

To make the ganache, simply place the chocolate and heavy cream in a microwave safe bowl and microwave on 30 second increments until melted and smooth. Allow to cool for about 5 minutes then pour over your set cheesecake.

Pipe with whipped cream and your favorite toppings and serve!

FAQ’S

1. CAN I USE A 6-INCH SPRINGFORM PAN?

A: Yes! You can absolutely use a 6 inch, just know that the cheesecake will be a little thicker. Add on about 5 minutes cook time.

2. MY CHEESECAKE LOOKS VERY UNDERCOOKED WHEN I REMOVE IT FROM THE INSTANT POT? IS IT DONE???

A: Yes! The cheesecake WILL look undercooked when you remove it from the Instant Pot, but trust me, just let it cool and place it in the refrigerator and it will be fine!

3. HOW LONG DOES MY CHEESECAKE HAVE TO SET BEFORE I CAN SERVE IT?

A: I recommend letting your cheesecake set overnight to fully set. However, if you are in a pinch, I would at LEAST let your cheesecake chill in the fridge for 6 hours.

Want More Instant Pot Cheesecake Recipes?

Instant Pot Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake

Instant Pot Oreo Cheesecake

Instant Pot Chocolate Cheesecake

Instant Pot Strawberry Cheesecake

If you love this Instant Pot Butterfinger Cheesecake as much as I do, make sure you share it with your friends on Facebook and Pinterest so they can make it too!